← Glossary

Guenzi's paradox

“If I create a solution for my customer, paradoxically I create a problem for my own company.” Every real proposition demands change inside the supplier.

Professor Paolo Guenzi put it as a paradox, at a meeting of the authors’ KAM Best Practice Club at Cranfield: “If I create a solution for my customer, paradoxically I create a problem for my own company.” The book calls it a key idea underneath everything else it says. The moment a supplier builds something genuinely tailored, better than the standard product at the standard price, it has asked its own organisation to do something it was not designed to do.

Why does a solution create a problem?

Because the supplier is built for standard work. Its portfolio of standard products is how it achieves scale, controls cost and stays efficient, and the whole machinery of the business is arranged to make the standard path easy. A tailored offer means operations has to make something different, finance has to price it differently, service has to support it, and someone’s target has to move. The book’s conclusion is that a real customer value proposition is never only a promise to the customer. If the change inside the supplier does not happen, the proposition dies on contact with the supplier’s own processes.

What does that look like on a real account?

The book’s example. A speciality chemicals supplier offered a manufacturer a managed service: it would take over the chemicals, the handling and the on-site expertise, in return for a share of the savings. The customer wanted it. It almost died inside the supplier. The sales team was paid on product volume, and this deal sold less product. Operations had never run an on-site service and was in no hurry to learn. Finance could not work out how to book the revenue. The proposition was sound; the internal change nearly killed it, and the account manager who made it work spent far more energy inside their own company than in front of the customer.

Figure

One solution for the customer, three problems at home.

The customer sees

Chemicals delivered to specification, at the standard price.

Chemicals, handling and on-site expertise, paid for from a share of the savings. They want it.

Inside the supplier
  • SalesPaid on volume. Business as usual.Paid on volume, and this deal sells less product.
  • OperationsShips product. Business as usual.Has never run an on-site service.
  • FinanceBooks product revenue. Business as usual.Cannot work out how to book the revenue.

The better the solution for the customer, the more of the supplier it asks to change.

The book's speciality chemicals example, from chapter 12. The two buttons compare the standard product with the managed service the customer wanted; the three internal problems are the ones the book names.

Where does it sit in the method?

It is why chapter 12 treats change not as a topic bolted onto the end of a book about value but as the whole subject, and why the book’s final definition of key account management includes leading the change that new value demands, inside the customer and inside the supplier’s own business. It explains the Cranfield finding that key account managers spend roughly 60% of their week inside their own organisation and only 30% with the customer (Marcos et al., 2018), and why every offer has to be sold twice, first to the supplier’s own leadership. It is also why the Change Agent sits among the Strategist’s four sub-skills in the KAM Skills Tri-Stack, and why a supplier that has built the hidden edge can absorb a bespoke offer that would choke a rival.

What it is not

It is not an argument against tailoring. The tension is built into the structure of any efficient business, and the book is clear it is not a failure of will. The paradox is the price of creating real value, and the answer is to get good at the change rather than to retreat to the standard offer, where the only thing left to compete on is price.

Set out in full in: Creating Customer Value Propositions with AI (Kogan Page, 2027), chapters 3 and 12.

Related terms

See the method run on one real account in three days: the One Page Proposition.