Problem statement
Four lines that close customer needs analysis: who will be helped, from what current state, to what better future state, so that they can achieve something they value.
A team can spend weeks understanding a customer and end up with a folder. The book has a name for analysis that never becomes anything the customer can feel: “an expensive way of being interested.” The problem statement is the cure. A value proposition is a solution, a solution answers a problem, so the whole of customer needs analysis converges on one clear statement of the customer’s problem.
What are the four lines?
The template is deliberately, almost insultingly, simple. We will assist a named person or business, to go from a current state that is hurting them, to a better future state, so that they can achieve something they value.
Each line draws on the work before it. The first demands a real person, not a company: the decider or the sponsor from the decision-making unit, someone specific. The middle two lines are the move from the small picture to the big picture: from what the customer asked for to the state its strategy actually needs, which is the future state the rest of the method builds towards. The last line is the value itself, the outcome the customer will reach that it cannot reach today.
What does a good one look like?
The book runs its environmental consultancy through the template. The person is the sustainability director of a European retail group. The current state is scrambling to prove net-zero compliance across a fragmented supply chain whose costs keep rising. The future state is a single audited programme that stays ahead of tightening regulation. And the prize is winning government contracts and protecting a brand that greenwashing could badly damage.
That one sentence names a person rather than a procurement inbox, describes a strategic need rather than a request for another compliance audit, and points at a prize the customer’s board cares about. Set beside it an illustrative weak version: “We will assist Acme Ltd to go from high costs to lower costs so that they can save money.” A company, a want restated as a need, and a prize nobody could measure or would fight for. The figure holds both, and a blank for a third.
Four lines, filled in.
We will assist the sustainability director of a European retail group to go from scrambling to prove net-zero compliance across a fragmented supply chain whose costs keep rising to a single audited programme that stays ahead of tightening regulation, so that they can win government contracts and protect a brand that greenwashing could badly damage.
A named person, a strategic need rather than another compliance audit, and a prize the board cares about.
Is it the value proposition?
Some practitioners treat the problem statement as the value proposition itself, and for a simple sale they are not far wrong. The book takes a different view: the statement is the seed rather than the plant, carried into offer ideation and grown into a full customer value proposition. Either way, nothing downstream is better than this sentence. Writing it is harder than writing a long report, because it forces a decision about what matters. Pascal once apologised for a long letter because he had not had time to write a shorter one.
Why does it matter more with AI?
The problem statement is where the human work hands over to the machine. Everything before it, the judgement, the relationships, the reading of a strategy nobody wrote down, is human. Once the problem is stated cleanly, AI has a brief it can generate, test and articulate solutions against at speed. Frame it badly and it returns fast, confident, beautifully written answers to the wrong question. Mark Davies covers the wider discipline in Problem framing.
Set out in full in: Creating Customer Value Propositions with AI (Kogan Page, 2027), chapter 5.
Related terms
Customer needs analysis
The diagnosis. Contextual intelligence about the customer's world, analytical depth about the problems underneath the problems, and clarity about who feels them.
Big picture and small picture
The small picture is what the customer asks for, in the tender. The big picture is what its strategy needs. The gap between the two is where a supplier adds value.
The future state
The customer's business as it will be once your promise is kept, described in their world and not yours. The centre of the wheel, in a dozen words.
Offer ideation
Diverge before you converge. The machine's gift is width; the cull is yours.
Customer value proposition
The answer to the customer's one real question: what is this worth to me? Said in two sentences, in their financial language.
Decision-making unit (DMU)
Everyone on the customer side who decides, influences, uses, pays for or can veto a purchase, mapped as seven roles and their relationships rather than job titles.
See the method run on one real account in three days: the One Page Proposition.