Win-loss review
A structured look, after the decision, at why a deal was really won or lost. Price is the reason most often given, and rarely the whole story.
A win-loss review is a structured look back at a decided deal, won or lost, to find out why it went the way it did. The useful version asks the customer, not just the sales team, and treats the first reason given as the start of the conversation rather than the answer. Across many deals, it shows patterns no single bid reveals.
Why is price the usual answer?
It is the easiest reason for everyone to give. A buyer who says “price” ends the conversation politely, with no need to describe an internal disagreement, a sceptical finance director or a fear of backing the wrong supplier. A seller who hears “price” is spared a harder diagnosis, because price is set by someone else in the business. The book makes the wider point about organisations: they drift back to talking about price “because price is concrete and value takes work.”
Price is sometimes the real reason. More often it is the only number left to argue about once nothing else has been made concrete. A customer who chooses on price alone, the book says, “is reading the first line of a long invoice and ignoring the rest.” If the supplier never showed the rest of the invoice, the total cost of ownership and the impact, then losing on price means losing on how the value was sold.
What does a review usually find instead?
Read across its chapters, the book points to several recurring causes. Many deals are not lost to a competitor at all: between 40% and 60% of qualified deals end in no decision (Dixon and McKenna, 2022), which is a fear of messing up and an unpriced cost of inaction, not a price problem. Some are lost before the tender is written: “most bids are already won or lost, quietly, in the months before, by whoever helped the customer frame the problem in the first place.” That is the small picture winning by default. Some are lost because the supplier was strong with the users and specifiers and nearly absent with the deciders, the gap the book maps across the decision-making unit. And some are lost inside the supplier, where an outcome promised by marketing is reframed by sales as a discount to get the order over the line.
Ten lost deals: the reason given, and the reason found.
Price 7
Timing, maybe next year 2
Stayed with the incumbent 1
Seven of ten losses put down to price.
How is a review run?
A review that teaches anything shares a few habits. It covers wins as well as losses, because the reason a deal was won is just as easy to misread. It happens soon after the decision, while the customer still remembers the meeting that turned it. It is often held by someone outside the deal team, so the customer is not being asked to criticise the person in front of them. And its findings go somewhere the next plan will read them: in the book’s living account plan, a synthesis worth keeping is written back as a permanent page rather than left in a debrief deck. The questions run back through the method. Was the customer’s problem framed in their money? Did the case reach the people who decide? Was there anything to make the decision safe?
Where does it sit, and what is it not?
It is a feedback loop for the whole cycle, close in spirit to performance review, which does the same job for an account already won. Across many deals it also explains causal ambiguity from the losing side: a competitor keeps winning work at prices that seem impossible, and no amount of studying its brochures explains why.
It is not a hunt for someone to blame, and it is not a survey with “price” as the first option. A review that confirms what the sales team already believed has usually only asked the sales team.
Set out in full in: Creating Customer Value Propositions with AI (Kogan Page, 2027), chapters 4, 5, 8, 9 and 10; Dixon and McKenna, The JOLT Effect (Portfolio, 2022).
Related terms
FOMU
Fear of messing up: stronger than fear of missing out, and the reason 40 to 60% of qualified deals end in no decision.
Cost of inaction
What the customer's problem costs them for every month nothing changes. The number that turns doing nothing from the safe default into a decision with a price.
Decision-making unit (DMU)
Everyone on the customer side who decides, influences, uses, pays for or can veto a purchase, mapped as seven roles and their relationships rather than job titles.
Big picture and small picture
The small picture is what the customer asks for, in the tender. The big picture is what its strategy needs. The gap between the two is where a supplier adds value.
Total cost of ownership
The whole burden of buying, running and living with a solution across its life. Price is only the first line, and the supplier who raises TCO first wins the framing.
Performance review
The eighth phase of the cycle: not an audit of a document but a coaching conversation about how the account is really being run, which becomes the first input to the next turn.
The living account plan
Something closer to a brain than a binder: an account plan an AI maintains from raw sources, against your methodology, so it is current when you open it.
Causal ambiguity
Advantage that competitors can watch but cannot reconstruct, because even the company holding it cannot fully explain it; AI copies the explicit, so this is where advantage now lives.
See the method run on one real account in three days: the One Page Proposition.