Cost of inaction
What the customer's problem costs them for every month nothing changes. The number that turns doing nothing from the safe default into a decision with a price.
The cost of inaction is what the customer’s problem costs them while nothing is done about it, usually counted per month or per year. It turns the status quo from a free option into a choice with a price. Most customers have never added it up. A supplier who does the arithmetic with them changes the question in the room: not whether the solution is worth its price, but how long the customer can afford to wait.
Why does doing nothing win so often?
Because it feels safe. Dixon and McKenna (2022), studying two and a half million recorded sales conversations, found that between 40% and 60% of qualified deals are lost not to a competitor but to no decision. The book reads that through two fears. The fear of missing out, the worry that standing still will cost them, helps the supplier. The fear of messing up, FOMU, pulls towards doing nothing, and it is the stronger of the two. The cost of inaction is the honest form of the first fear: not urgency added by the seller, but a number the customer can check.
How is it worked out?
It starts from the customer’s problem in the customer’s money, which is the Agitate step of P.A.I.N.S.: bringing clarity to a cost that usually stays hidden. The book’s example is a customer whose situation is quietly costing half a million a year; set against that, a £150,000 solution “stops looking like an expense and starts looking like a return.” Divide the annual cost by twelve and the customer is paying about £42,000 for every month the decision waits. On those numbers, four months of waiting costs more than the solution.
The inputs have to be the customer’s, measured against a baseline they agree, or the figure is a sales claim. The costs tend to sit where the book finds them inside total cost of ownership: the costs of operating, and the costs of not operating, the planned and unplanned stoppages, the changeovers, the inspections. The book’s pharmaceutical example shows what happens when nobody does the sum. On a twenty-million-pound site, where a slipped validation date is measured in millions, not one layer of the supply chain asked what a delay would cost.
What waiting costs, month by month.
Months of waiting
Where does it sit in the method?
The cost of inaction is the impact side of the value equation seen from the other direction: impact the customer could bank, counted as impact they are losing. It belongs in the problem statement and in the business case the decision-making unit takes to its own finance team. The supplier-centric propositions that stall deals rarely carry such a number. The book asks the same question inside the supplier, as part of the internal pitch: “what happens if you do nothing?”
What it is not
It is not a scare figure. An inflated cost of inaction feeds the very fear the buyer already has, because a bigger claim is a bigger thing to be wrong about. A credible figure is conservative, built from the customer’s numbers, and comes with assurance: a pilot, a staged rollout, a clean exit if the first milestone misses. Nor does it justify any price. If the problem costs less than the solution over a sensible horizon, doing nothing is the right answer today, and P.A.I.N.S. calls saying so the courage to stop.
Set out in full in: Creating Customer Value Propositions with AI (Kogan Page, 2027), chapters 4, 8 and 10; Dixon and McKenna, The JOLT Effect (Portfolio, 2022).
Related terms
FOMU
Fear of messing up: stronger than fear of missing out, and the reason 40 to 60% of qualified deals end in no decision.
The P.A.I.N.S. value-selling cycle
Problem, Agitate, Indicate, Navigate, Solution: a cycle for selling value that starts with what the customer's problem is costing them, not with the product.
The baseline
The measure agreed before delivery starts. Value measured against a remembered past is value the customer will dispute.
Value equals impact minus total cost of ownership
Value is what remains when you take the whole cost of having the solution from the impact the customer can bank.
Total cost of ownership
The whole burden of buying, running and living with a solution across its life. Price is only the first line, and the supplier who raises TCO first wins the framing.
Assurance
The corner of the proposition that answers why should I believe you: credibility, return on investment, and the measures both sides will use.
Problem statement
Four lines that close customer needs analysis: who will be helped, from what current state, to what better future state, so that they can achieve something they value.
Win-loss review
A structured look, after the decision, at why a deal was really won or lost. Price is the reason most often given, and rarely the whole story.
See the method run on one real account in three days: the One Page Proposition.