← Insights

Why Supplier-Centric Value Propositions Stall Deals

Most value propositions describe the supplier, then leave a buying group of 13 people to work out what it means for them. Why that stalls deals, and how to rewrite one.

In May 2026, Gartner ran a roundtable called “Empowering Sellers With Buyer-Centric Value Propositions” at its CSO and Sales Leader Conference in Las Vegas. It ran on both days, the second time as a multi-group session. Four months earlier, Forrester had opened its year with a report on business buying under the headline that buyers demand proof, not promises.

Two research firms, two conferences, one complaint. Sales teams are still sending out value propositions that talk about themselves.

Most of those propositions don’t lose. They stall. The buyer likes the meeting, asks for the deck, says they’ll take it to the team, and then nothing happens for three months. This piece is about why, and about what a proposition looks like when it is written for the people who have to decide.

What makes a value proposition supplier-centric?

The quickest tell is the subject of each sentence. “We are a market leader.” “Our platform integrates with everything.” “Our team has 20 years of experience.” Every sentence is about the supplier. The customer appears, if at all, as the person who will receive all this excellence.

James Anderson, James Narus and Wouter van Rossum described the pattern twenty years ago in Harvard Business Review (Anderson, Narus and van Rossum, 2006). They found three ways suppliers build a proposition. The first lists every benefit the offer might deliver, which leads to what they called benefit assertion: claiming advantages for features the customer doesn’t care about. The second explains why you are better than a competitor, which leads to value presumption: assuming that any difference must be worth something to the customer. Only the third, which they called resonating focus, starts from the one or two things that matter most to this customer’s business, and proves superior performance on those.

Benefit assertion and value presumption are both supplier-centric. They start from what the supplier has and hope the customer will find a use for it. Most of the propositions sent out this year still sit in one of those two camps, which is why Gartner needed the roundtable.

A customer value proposition answers the customer’s one real question, which is what this is worth to them, in their own financial language. A supplier-centric one answers a question nobody asked.

Why does that stall a deal instead of losing it?

Because the buyer can’t take it to the rest of the buying group.

Forrester’s latest survey of nearly 18,000 business buyers puts the average buying group at 13 internal people and nine external influencers. For purchases with generative AI features, the internal group doubles, from seven to 14 (Forrester, 2026). In its 2024 study, Forrester found that 89% of purchases involve two or more departments, and that 86% of B2B purchases stall at some point in the buying process (Forrester, 2024).

And the supplier is in very little of that conversation. Gartner’s research on the buying journey found that buyers spend about 17% of their buying time meeting potential suppliers, and that is all suppliers together. With three in the running, each one gets roughly 5% (Gartner, 2018).

So the proposition has to do its work in the other 95%, in meetings you are not invited to. Your contact walks into a room with finance, operations, procurement, IT and the people who will actually use the thing, and has to explain why it matters. If your proposition says “we are the market leader in integrated coatings”, they now have to translate that into a saving, a risk reduced or a target hit, on the spot, for five different listeners. Most people won’t try. The safest thing to do with a proposition you can’t explain is to leave it on the pile.

That is what a stall looks like from the inside. Matthew Dixon and Ted McKenna’s analysis of 2.5 million recorded sales calls found that between 40% and 60% of qualified pipeline is lost to no decision, and that more than half of those losses come from the buyer’s fear of making the wrong choice, not from loyalty to the status quo (Dixon and McKenna). A proposition the buyer can’t explain is a proposition the buyer can’t defend. Of course they hesitate.

What does each person in the buying group need to hear?

Something different, and something they can repeat. The figure shows the same supplier pitch through five pairs of eyes; click a role.

Figure 1

One pitch, five listeners

The supplier says

“We’re the market leader in industrial coatings, with 20 years of R&D and a patented fast-cure formula.”

The roles follow the usual shape of a decision-making unit. The coatings company is invented for this figure.

Across the five, the questions are about what changes for each of them, how much it is worth, and what happens to them if it goes wrong. Whether you are good comes up only as part of the last one. Procurement wants a number to compare. Finance wants a number it can bank. Operations wants to know what breaks during the switch. The user wants to know whether their day gets better or worse. The person who sponsors the purchase wants a sentence they can say in the next leadership meeting without being caught out.

A supplier-centric proposition gives each of them homework. A buyer-centric one gives each of them an answer.

What does a defensible proposition contain?

Four things, and in this order.

It starts with the customer’s problem, described in their words and, where possible, in their numbers: hours of downtime, days of delay, cost per unit, customers lost. If you can’t describe the problem without mentioning your product, you don’t understand it yet.

Then it puts a size on the outcome, in money, against the customer’s next best alternative. Anderson and his colleagues called this a value word equation: a sentence that says, in words and arithmetic, how the difference in performance turns into money (Anderson, Narus and van Rossum, 2006). The value equation on this site is the same idea from the other side: the impact the customer can bank, minus the whole cost of having the solution.

Then it shows proof that you can deliver: a reference from a similar customer, a pilot, a guarantee.

Finally, it agrees how the result will be measured, against a baseline agreed before you start. This is the part most suppliers skip, and it is the part that turns a promise into the proof Forrester’s buyers say they want.

That is the anatomy. Here it is applied to a real-sounding pitch.

What does the rewrite look like?

Each stage of the figure replaces one line of supplier language with something the customer can use.

Figure 2

From supplier claim to customer outcome

    An invented example with invented numbers. The arithmetic: 11 hours a month is 132 hours a year; 60% of that is about 79 hours; at £2,400 an hour, that is roughly £190,000 a year.

    The finished version is longer than the original, and it doesn’t mention market leadership, R&D or patents at all. They haven’t gone away. They have moved to where they belong, as the proof behind a claim the customer cares about. The patent matters because it is why the cure time is shorter. The 20 years matter because they mean there is a reference customer with a similar line.

    The rewrite also needs two things the original didn’t: the customer’s downtime figure and their cost per hour. You can’t write a buyer-centric proposition from your own brochure. You have to have asked. This is where a high-impact value proposition differs from a pitch, because it speaks to a problem the customer actually has, and it carries proof.

    How can you test a proposition before a customer does?

    Language gives a supplier-centric proposition away faster than anything. The figure checks it: paste in one of yours, or edit the example.

    Figure 3

    Who is your proposition about?

    About you: 0About the customer: 0

      A rough check, not a grade. It counts words about you (we, our, us, your company’s favourite adjectives) against words about the customer, and looks for a number, a currency and a measure. Nothing you type leaves this page.

      A word count is a blunt tool, and a proposition can pass it and still be wrong. The sharper test is a person. Give the proposition to someone playing each role in the buying group and see what they say when they repeat it in one sentence to an imaginary colleague. If finance repeats it as a saving and the user repeats it as a better shift, it works. If they all repeat your company name, it doesn’t.

      Value Matters built the DMU Simulator for exactly that test. It runs a proposition past a simulated buying group and shows how each member reacts, before you put it in front of the real one.

      Does AI make this better or worse?

      Both, depending on what you feed it.

      Forrester found that 94% of business buyers now use AI during the buying process, and that they check what it tells them against people they trust (Forrester, 2026). In practice, your proposition will often be summarised by a machine before a person reads it. A summary of a supplier-centric pitch is a shorter supplier-centric pitch. A summary of a proposition built on the customer’s problem and a number still carries the problem and the number.

      On the selling side, it is now trivially easy to generate polished propositions at scale, and most of them read like the original in Figure 2. Forrester made the point after its own summit, in a post titled AI Is Everywhere In GTM. Customer Value Isn’t. The tools can draft, restructure and rehearse. They can play a sceptical CFO, which is useful practice. They can’t supply the customer’s downtime figure or the customer’s agreement that it’s right.

      So where does a rewrite start?

      With one live opportunity, and one question. What would the person sponsoring this deal say about it, in one sentence, if they had to explain it to their boss in a corridor?

      If the honest answer is your company’s name and a superlative, the proposition isn’t finished. If it is a problem they own, a number they believe and a date when they will know, it might be.

      Sources: Anderson, J.C., Narus, J.A. and van Rossum, W. (2006) “Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets”, Harvard Business Review, March 2006; Dixon, M. (n.d.) “How to change indecisive customers into buyers”, Raconteur, drawing on Dixon, M. and McKenna, T. (2022) The JOLT Effect, Portfolio; Forrester (2024) “To Master B2B Buying Mayhem, Providers Must Prioritize Buyers’ Needs”, press release on The State Of Business Buying, 2024; Forrester (2026) “The State Of Business Buying: Risk-Averse Buyers Demand Proof, Not Promises”; Forrester (2026) “AI Is Everywhere In GTM. Customer Value Isn’t”; Gartner (2018) “How B2B Sales Reps Maximize Customer Interactions”; Gartner (2026) CSO and Sales Leader Conference, session catalogue, Las Vegas, 19 to 20 May 2026.

      If this is your problem too, score your account with the Value Edge Diagnostic, or talk to us.

      The newsletter this came from

      Every fortnight: one idea from the method, worked through properly. Read it where you already are, on LinkedIn, or by email below.

      Keep reading